The horrifying acid attack on Dr. Mahnoor Nasir, a young postgraduate resident at the Civil Hospital in Quetta, is a deeply upsetting reminder of the dangers that working women face in Pakistan. That a doctor could be brutally targeted while on duty inside a major government hospital is a massive failure of both workplace security and societal values. It shows that even the most educated women are not safe from extreme violence when they try to perform their professional duties.
According to police and hospital officials, the attacker was a lift operator employed at the same hospital who had been harassing Dr. Mahnoor for months. When his unwanted advances were rejected, his toxic entitlement turned into extreme violence. He knocked on the door of the doctor’s room in the surgery ward and threw a bottle of corrosive acid directly at her face and body. The attack caused deep burn wounds across thirteen percent of her body, including her face, arms, and legs. Because of the severity of her injuries, she had to be urgently flown to Karachi via an air ambulance for specialized plastic surgery and eye care.
While the police tracked down the suspect and killed him in a shootout near a bus terminal shortly after the crime, this final action does not solve the underlying problem. A police encounter cannot undo the physical and mental trauma inflicted upon the victim. It does not erase the months of fear she faced due to harassment, nor does it fix the broken security system that allowed an employee to carry out such a heinous act during broad daylight in a secure medical ward. Amidst this tragedy, the incredible bravery of a hospital ward boy, Abdul Razzaq Tarakai, must be recognized. He risked his own safety to defend the doctor during the attack and was also injured. His quick action saved her life and stands as a rare example of humanity in an otherwise dark situation.
This incident exposes how deeply unsafe our public workplaces have become for women. Hospitals are supposed to be safe spaces for healing, yet female medical professionals are increasingly facing harassment and hostility from colleagues, staff, and visitors. The Young Doctors Association rightly went on strike to protest this attack, keeping only emergency rooms open. It is completely unfair to expect medical professionals to save the lives of citizens when the state cannot even guarantee their basic survival while they are on the clock.
This tragedy points to two major systemic failures that need immediate fixing. First, there is a dangerous tendency within institutions to ignore early signs of harassment, allowing bad behavior to grow into catastrophic violence. Phone records showed the suspect had been targeting her for months, yet no one stopped him. Second, despite multiple laws and court rulings meant to regulate dangerous chemicals, it is still shockingly easy for anyone to buy or access acid in Pakistan.
It is commendable that the Balochistan government acted quickly to send Dr. Mahnoor to Karachi and promised to pay for all her medical bills and recovery. However, financial help and official statements of condemnation are simply not enough anymore. To make sure no other female doctor or worker has to experience this nightmare, the state must implement real structural changes. Every public institution must have a functional, independent committee where women can safely report harassment without fear of being ignored. Security inside government hospitals must be completely overhauled, with restricted access to doctors’ duty rooms so that unauthorized personnel cannot simply walk in. Most importantly, the laws governing the sale of acid must be strictly enforced, and anyone selling or carrying it illegally must face severe criminal penalties.
Pakistan cannot progress, talk about gender equality, or encourage women to join the workforce if it fails to protect them from life-altering violence. When a doctor is attacked inside a major provincial hospital, it sends a terrifying message to every family and every young woman striving for financial independence. True justice for Dr. Mahnoor Nasir will not come from a police shootout; it will only come when our institutions take harassment seriously and guarantee that no woman has to risk her life to practice her profession.
Also Read: The Script Must Change: Time to Retire the ‘Pathan’ Stereotype
Today's E-Paper