The Fragrance of Paper, the Hunger of Machines

Share f X WA in

November had settled over Lahore as a pink haze that morning. It was that rosy season in which the air brushes the cheeks with a faint chill and the sun lands shyly on the walls. In that morning on Mall Road, along with the steam of my tea, an old scene rose up too. At the Sunday book stall stood the same Baba Ji from whom I used to buy books as a child. I would pick up my Imran Series novels there and listen to his words of learning and good upbringing. When my pocket fell short, instead of buying the book I would simply listen to the next installment from him. He would tell the story, and I would stand right there, forgetting my lack of money, lost in the fragrance of paper.

Today, too, Baba Ji had arranged his rare books, novels, biographies, and short stories with his usual care. People came, turned over the covers, paused for a while, and moved on. A well-known professor also came quietly, looked through a few books, bought some, and left.

There was a familiar sadness in the scene. Once, book stalls drew both children and adults. Parents did not confine their children to textbooks; through stories, novels, and biographies they awakened in them a desire to read and to know. Now school libraries are not what they used to be, and homes have no special place or time for reading. In many of our government schools, books stay locked behind cupboards; the knowledge exists, but out of the children’s reach. The bookseller’s voice, the scent of paper, and a few faces bent over books reminded me that the quality of education is built not only on syllabus and exams, but on the habit of reading.

With this thought, I remembered the theme of a session at IFLA WLIC 2026: “Between rejection and extraction: GenAI, copyright and access to library collections.” It dealt with a difficult tension facing libraries. On one side are copyright bodies and publishers, who want to stop their books and content from being used to train artificial intelligence. On the other, AI companies need this very material at large scale so their models can learn. Libraries thus stand between two pressures: on one side the fear that public access to knowledge will be restricted, on the other the risk that their precious collections will be exploited commercially without limit.

The legal path is not the same everywhere either. The European Union has specific rules on text and data mining for research, while in the United States many questions depend on how courts interpret “fair use.” As a result, it is not easy for libraries and researchers to understand which uses are permitted and which are not. The session’s participants therefore spoke of a “middle path”: libraries should not surrender their legal rights, should not accept agreements that weaken the right of access granted by law, and should use their reliable, curated collections to create transparent and ethical data.

The example of the National Library of Sweden offers hope here. It showed a way to responsibly include high-quality data on the national language and cultural heritage in AI development, while respecting the country’s copyright exceptions. This makes clear that libraries are not merely custodians of content; they can also help decide how knowledge reaches new technology.

But this requires clear and transparent agreements. Libraries should enter partnerships with AI developers in which the limits of use, the public interest, and the purposes of research are plainly stated. The aim is neither to reject every new technology nor to hand over book collections to anyone without conditions. The real question is: will AI serve knowledge, or reduce knowledge to mere commercial raw material?

The pink morning was fading and the tea had gone cold, but I felt that the world of books was already losing our attention. Artificial intelligence can narrow that distance, if the knowledge of libraries reaches it responsibly, and it can widen it, if we neglect the book, the reader, and the public right of access. Machines can learn from books, but the love of books and the habit of asking questions must be instilled by humans in their own children. The danger is not only that machines will begin to read books; the real danger is that humans will move away from them

Follow The Public Purview on WhatsApp